A product’s appearance can be one of its most valuable commercial features. Whether it is the distinctive shape of a chair, the configuration of a lighting fixture, or the design of a handbag, considerable time and resources may be invested in creating something that stands apart from competing products.

Many designers and businesses assume that because they created the product and own the original drawings, copyright will prevent others from copying it. Under Australian law, however, that assumption can be costly.

The Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) and the Designs Act 2003 (Cth) provide different forms of intellectual property protection. Although both can concern the appearance of a product, they operate differently, and Australian law places important restrictions on relying on copyright where an artistic work has been reproduced as a commercial product.

For businesses intending to manufacture and sell products, understanding these restrictions is essential.

What Does Copyright Protect?

Copyright protection arises automatically in Australia when an original artistic work is created, provided the relevant statutory requirements are satisfied. There is no requirement to register copyright.

Artistic works protected under the Copyright Act 1968 can include drawings, illustrations, photographs, sculptures and works of artistic craftsmanship.

For example, a designer who prepares original drawings for a new furniture product may own copyright in those drawings. Copyright generally gives the owner the exclusive right to reproduce the artistic work, including reproductions of a substantial part of it.

That said, copyright can further extend beyond direct copying of a drawing. Under section 21(3) of the Copyright Act, reproducing a two-dimensional artistic work in three-dimensional form may also constitute reproduction of that work.

However, this protection is subject to specific provisions governing the relationship between copyright and registered designs.

The difficulty arises when the artistic work is used to manufacture products for commercial sale.

How Registered Design Protection Differs?

Registered designs protect the overall visual appearance of a product rather than the underlying artistic work.

Under the Designs Act 2003, a design concerns the overall appearance of a product resulting from one or more visual features, including its shape, configuration, pattern or ornamentation.

Examples of products that may qualify for registered design protection include furniture, lighting fixtures, packaging, footwear, household appliances, fashion accessories and industrial components.

To qualify for protection, a design must be new and distinctive when compared with the relevant prior art.

One of the principal differences between copyright and registered designs concerns infringement.

Copyright infringement generally requires reproduction of a substantial part of a protected work. A person who independently creates a similar work without copying the original will not ordinarily infringe copyright.

Registered design infringement does not depend on proving that the competing manufacturer actually copied the registered design.

Under section 71 of the Designs Act, infringement may occur where a person makes, imports, sells or otherwise commercially deals with a product embodying a design that is identical or substantially similar in overall impression to the registered design, subject to the statutory requirements and exceptions.

This distinction is particularly important where competitors manufacture products with similar appearances but there is insufficient evidence that they copied the original drawings.

In Australia, design registration initially lasts for five years from the filing date and can be renewed once for a further five years, providing a maximum protection period of ten years.

A registered design must also undergo examination and be certified by IP Australia before its owner can commence infringement proceedings.

The Copyright and Designs Overlap

Australian law does not generally allow copyright to serve as a substitute for registered design protection where an artistic work has been commercially exploited as a three-dimensional product.

Sections 74 to 77 of the Copyright Act address the interaction between the two forms of protection.

Section 74 defines a corresponding design by reference to visual features of shape or configuration that, when embodied in a product, reproduce an artistic work.

Section 77 is particularly significant for businesses that manufacture products without registering their designs.

Broadly, where a corresponding design has been applied industrially by or with the authority of the copyright owner, and products embodying that design have been sold or offered for sale or hire, the Copyright Act may prevent the owner from relying on copyright to stop others reproducing the corresponding design in products.

Regulation 12 of the Copyright Regulations 2017 (Cth) provides that a design is taken to have been applied industrially if it has been applied to:

  1. More than 50 articles; or
  2. One or more articles, other than handmade articles, manufactured in lengths or pieces.

The number of articles is therefore an important consideration, although industrial application is not necessarily limited to these circumstances.

The statutory provisions also apply to relevant commercial activities occurring outside Australia.

Importantly, the limitation is not simply triggered by creating the original drawings or manufacturing a prototype. The operation of section 77 depends on its statutory conditions, including industrial application and the relevant commercial dealings. Separate provisions also address the publication of certain patent specifications and design application representations.

Why is this important?

Consider a furniture business that develops an original chair with a distinctive shape.

The designer prepares detailed drawings and three-dimensional models before arranging commercial production. The business subsequently manufactures and offers more than 50 chairs for sale.

A competing manufacturer later introduces a chair with substantially the same appearance.

The original business may assume that its copyright in the design drawings provides sufficient grounds to prevent the competing product from being sold.

However, if the requirements of section 77 are satisfied, reproducing the corresponding design in another chair may not infringe copyright, even if the competing product closely resembles the original design.

The existence of copyright in the drawings does not necessarily provide an enforceable right against the manufacture of competing three-dimensional products.

If the business has also failed to obtain registered design protection, it may have limited options for preventing competitors from adopting the same product appearance.

This is precisely the situation that the copyright and designs overlap provisions are intended to address.

Does Registering a Design Affect Copyright?

Registration can also affect the extent to which copyright may be enforced.

Under section 75 of the Copyright Act, where a corresponding design has been registered under the Designs Act, reproducing the artistic work by embodying that design, or another corresponding design, in a product does not ordinarily constitute copyright infringement.

The copyright in the underlying artistic work is not necessarily extinguished altogether. Rather, the legislation limits the acts against which copyright can be enforced.

For product manufacturers, the practical consequence is that protection against competing products will generally need to be pursued through the registered design regime.

Once the design has been registered and certified, the owner can rely on the exclusive rights available under the Designs Act.

Are There Exceptions to the Copyright and Designs Overlap?

The interaction between copyright and registered designs is not absolute.

Two-Dimensional Patterns and Ornamentation

An important distinction exists between the three-dimensional shape of a product and artistic works reproduced as two-dimensional patterns or ornamentation on its surface.

For example, an original illustration printed on a T-shirt or a decorative pattern applied to fabric may continue to receive copyright protection even where the product is commercially manufactured.

In appropriate circumstances, the appearance of the product incorporating that artwork may also qualify for registered design protection.

Consequently, dual protection may be available for certain surface decorations.

However, this distinction does not mean that every decorative feature applied to a commercial product automatically receives both forms of protection. The nature of the artistic work, the manner in which it is reproduced and the relevant statutory requirements must be considered.

Works of Artistic Craftsmanship

Section 77 also contains an exception for works of artistic craftsmanship, as well as certain buildings and models of buildings.

A qualifying work of artistic craftsmanship may retain copyright protection despite being industrially applied, provided the circumstances do not otherwise engage restrictions such as those arising from design registration.

However, establishing that a product is a work of artistic craftsmanship is not straightforward.

A product does not qualify merely because it is attractive, distinctive or carefully designed.

The courts consider whether the work possesses the necessary artistic character, including the extent to which its design was influenced by functional requirements.

What Have Australian Courts Said?

The difficulty of relying on copyright to protect commercial product designs was demonstrated in State of Escape Accessories Pty Limited v Schwartz [2022] FCAFC 63.

The dispute involved a distinctive neoprene tote bag featuring perforated neoprene material and sailing rope handles.

State of Escape alleged copyright infringement in relation to competing bags and sought to establish that its bag was a work of artistic craftsmanship.

The Federal Court rejected that argument, and the Full Federal Court dismissed the subsequent appeal.

The Full Court accepted that the bag involved design choices and aesthetic considerations. However, it agreed that the design was substantially constrained by functional considerations.

The combination of materials and design features did not establish that the bag qualified as a work of artistic craftsmanship under the Copyright Act.

The decision illustrates an important limitation of copyright protection for commercial products.

A product may be original, visually distinctive and commercially successful without necessarily qualifying as a work of artistic craftsmanship.

Businesses should therefore be cautious about assuming that the artistic merit of a product will be sufficient to preserve copyright protection once the product enters commercial production.

Why Should Design Registration Be Considered Before Product Launch?

For businesses developing products with distinctive appearances, the timing of design protection is particularly important.

Under the Designs Act, a design must satisfy the requirements of newness and distinctiveness.

Public disclosure before filing a design application can affect whether these requirements are satisfied.

Such disclosures may include publishing product photographs on a website, promoting the design on social media, displaying products at trade exhibitions or offering products for sale.

Australia introduced a 12-month grace period for certain disclosures under amendments that commenced on 10 March 2022.

The grace period may allow a design owner to obtain registration despite having publicly disclosed the design within the preceding 12 months, provided the statutory conditions are satisfied.

However, the grace period is not an unconditional entitlement to registration.

It does not cover every type of disclosure, and intervening third-party activities may affect the scope of rights that can subsequently be enforced. Public disclosures may also create difficulties for obtaining corresponding design protection overseas.

Accordingly, the safer approach is generally to file a design application before the product is publicly disclosed.

Copyright and Registered Designs Serve Different Commercial Purposes

Copyright remains valuable for protecting original artistic works, including illustrations, drawings, photographs and other creative material associated with a product.

Registered designs serve a different purpose. They provide a specific legal mechanism for protecting a product’s visual appearance against competing commercial products.

The distinction becomes particularly important where the commercial value lies in the physical appearance of the product itself.

A business that owns the original design drawings may still be unable to prevent another manufacturer from producing a substantially similar product if the copyright and designs overlap provisions apply.

Conversely, a registered and certified design can provide enforceable rights against products that are substantially similar in overall impression, without requiring proof that the competing manufacturer copied the original artistic work.

For businesses investing in product development, relying exclusively on copyright may therefore leave an important part of their intellectual property unprotected.

Conclusion

Copyright and registered designs are complementary forms of intellectual property protection, but they are not interchangeable.

Australian law draws a deliberate distinction between protecting original artistic works and protecting the appearance of products manufactured for commercial purposes.

The copyright and designs overlap provisions can significantly restrict the protection available to designers who commercialise their products without first considering design registration.

Although exceptions exist, particularly for two-dimensional artistic works and works of artistic craftsmanship, these exceptions should not be assumed to apply to ordinary commercial products.

For designers, manufacturers and businesses preparing to launch new products, the appropriate protection strategy should be considered during the development stage, rather than after competing products have entered the market.

At LexGeneris, we assist businesses and designers with Australian design searches, registration, examination, certification and enforcement. Early advice can help identify which aspects of a product are protectable and whether copyright, registered designs or a combination of intellectual property rights is appropriate.

Contact us to learn more about how LexGeneris can assist you with all your intellectual property needs. You can also schedule a no-cost consultation with our team of expert IP Attorneys Australia, IP Attorneys India, and IP Attorneys New Zealand